Light LiftAI

Guides / Software

Rent or own: when custom software beats a subscription

By Brendan Winters, Light Lift AI. Updated .

The short answer

Rent software when your need is common and one tool fits it well. Own custom software when you pay for several tools that do not connect, or when you bend your business to fit the tool. AI has made custom software much faster to build, so owning now makes sense for many more small businesses.

When renting is the right choice

Subscriptions are good for jobs every business does the same way. Email, accounting, payroll and video calls are examples. The tool is ready today, someone else keeps it running, and your need is not special. Keep renting these.

Five signs you should own it

  1. You pay for several tools that overlap. Each one does part of the job, and you pay for all of them.
  2. Your team copies information between tools. The tools do not read each other, so people do it by hand.
  3. You use a small part of a big tool. You pay for a hundred features and use six.
  4. You change how you work to fit the tool. The software should fit the business, not the other way round.
  5. The price goes up with every user or every customer. Growing costs you more each month.

What changed

Custom software used to take a team of developers many months. For most small businesses that put it out of reach. AI now does much of the heavy lifting in the build. I can build in weeks what used to take much longer, and that lowers the cost.

An example from my own company

At Pro Skills Basketball we rented Airtable, Zapier, LeagueApps and SportsRecruits. Each did one part of the job. They did not fit how we run, and people filled the gaps by hand.

I replaced all four with software we own. That saves us more than $100,000 a year. One app now handles registration, payments, email and texts for our players, parents, coaches and staff. The history from LeagueApps moved across with it: about 34,000 families and 37,900 players. Because it is one system, the parts read each other, and more of the work runs on its own.

What owning means

When I build software for you, it is yours. Your app, your data, your accounts. There is no lock-in. I train your team and hand it over. If you want more later, we can talk.

Owning has costs too. Software you own still needs hosting, and it may need changes as your business changes. For a common job, that is not worth it. For the work that makes your business different, it often is.

How to decide

List every tool you pay for. Next to each one, write what you use it for and what your team does by hand around it. If three or four tools on the list do parts of one job, that job is a good one to own.

Common questions

Is custom software only for big companies?

Not any more. AI has made custom software much faster to build, so it now makes sense for many small and mid-size businesses.

Who owns custom software that Light Lift AI builds?

You do. Your apps, your data and your accounts. There is no lock-in.

Should I replace all my subscriptions?

No. Keep renting tools for common jobs like email and accounting. Own the software for the work that is specific to your business.

Book a free call

A free 30-minute call. I look at where your team loses the most time and we pick the first thing to fix.

More guides